Guides · Types of case

Your small business has a contract dispute

A customer will not pay, a supplier did not deliver, or a partner walked away. What to check in the contract first, and how to weigh a fight against what it costs.

Most contract disputes start as a business problem: an unpaid invoice, a late delivery, work that was not what was promised. They turn into legal problems gradually, and what you do early often decides how expensive that becomes.

Read the contract before anything else

Look for these clauses in particular, because they often decide the next move:

  • Notice and cure. Many contracts require written notice of a problem, and a chance to fix it, before you can end the deal or claim damages.
  • Dispute resolution. An arbitration clause may send the dispute to a private arbitrator rather than a court. Some contracts require mediation first.
  • Governing law and venue. A clause may say which state's law applies and where any case has to be brought, which can be a long way from you.
  • Legal fees. In the United States each side usually pays its own lawyers. A contract clause can change that, so check whether yours has one.
  • Limits on liability. Some contracts cap what can be recovered or exclude certain kinds of loss.

If there was no written contract, or the deal changed over emails and phone calls, you may still have an enforceable agreement. It becomes more a question of evidence.

Gather the paper trail

Collect the contract and every amendment, along with purchase orders, invoices, change orders, delivery records and all the emails and messages about the deal. Do not delete anything, including things that look unhelpful. Once a dispute is likely, destroying records can cause serious trouble on its own.

Be careful about stopping your side

When the other party falls short, the instinct is to stop work or stop paying. Sometimes that is justified. Sometimes it turns you into the party in breach. Get advice before you stop performing, terminate the contract, or send a letter saying you are about to.

Weigh the fight against what it costs

Litigation is often slow and expensive, and winning a judgment is not the same as collecting the money. Ask a lawyer for an honest estimate of what each stage will cost and compare it with what you could realistically recover. A demand letter from a lawyer often prompts a settlement, or at least a serious conversation, and mediation can get there too. For smaller amounts, small claims court may be an option, though the limits, and whether a business can appear there without a lawyer, differ by state.

Cost and timing

Business disputes are usually billed hourly, though some lawyers will consider contingency or a mix of the two. How lawyers charge explains what to pin down. Contract claims have time limits as well. They vary by state and by type of contract, and some contracts shorten them. If you would like a member who handles business disputes to take a look, you can describe the dispute here.

General information about business contract disputes, not advice about your contract. What your own agreement actually says matters more than anything on this page.

Every attorney in this network is checked by a person before being approved, and again every year.

Tell us what you need