Referral fee rules · Pennsylvania to New York

Referring a case from Pennsylvania to New York

Can the referring lawyer take a referral fee?

Not for the referral alone.

New York does not permit a fee for the referral alone. Because each lawyer is bound by their own state's rule, the split has to track the work each firm does, or both firms have to take joint responsibility for the matter.

Client consent: under the stricter of the two rules, the client's agreement has to be in writing.

Draft the Pennsylvania to New York agreement

When a lawyer admitted in Pennsylvania sends a matter to a lawyer admitted in New York, each of them is bound by the professional conduct rule of the state where they are licensed. A fee division that satisfies one state and not the other is still a problem for the lawyer whose rule it breaks, so the practical answer is to meet both. Where the two rules differ, follow the stricter one.

Referring lawyer

Pennsylvania

Pa.R.P.C. 1.5(e) (204 Pa. Code § 81.4, Rule 1.5) · Pure referral fee permitted

Pennsylvania permits pure referral fees. A lawyer may divide a fee with a lawyer not in the same firm if the client is advised of and does not object to the participation of all the lawyers involved, and the total fee is not illegal or clearly excessive. There is no proportionality or joint-responsibility requirement, no written-consent requirement, and no requirement to disclose the share each lawyer receives.

  • •Client advised of and does not object to participation of all lawyers involved
  • •Total fee not illegal or clearly excessive
  • •No proportionality or joint-responsibility requirement
  • •No writing or share-disclosure requirement in the rule text
Read the Pennsylvania rule text

Receiving lawyer

New York

N.Y. Rules of Professional Conduct Rule 1.5(g) (22 NYCRR 1200.0) · Proportional work or joint responsibility

New York places its fee-division rule in Rule 1.5(g) rather than 1.5(e). A lawyer may not divide a fee with a lawyer outside the firm unless the division is proportional to services performed or, by a writing given to the client, each lawyer assumes joint responsibility for the representation. The client must agree to the other lawyer's employment after full disclosure that fees will be divided, including the share each lawyer will receive, with the client's agreement confirmed in writing. The total fee must not be excessive.

  • •Division proportional to services OR joint responsibility assumed by a writing given to the client
  • •Client agrees to employment of the other lawyer after full disclosure of the division, including each lawyer's share
  • •Client's agreement confirmed in writing
  • •Total fee not excessive
Read the New York rule text

If you were planning a pure referral fee

  • New York (N.Y. Rules of Professional Conduct Rule 1.5(g) (22 NYCRR 1200.0)) does not permit a pure referral fee. The division must either track the work each firm does, or both firms must assume joint responsibility under a written client agreement.

Educational summary, not legal advice. Rules change and several turn on the facts of the matter, such as whether it is a contingency case. Confirm against the current rule text in both states before agreeing to divide a fee.

Need counsel in New York?

Attorney Connect is a free network of verified attorneys who refer matters to each other across state lines. Members draft compliant fee agreements in a minute and track the referral fees they are owed.

Other referrals out of Pennsylvania